Collections

Wheat Bread

$6.35

Sourdough Bread *Available after 11am

$6.45

Wheat Bread

$6.35

Sourdough Bread *Available after 11am

$6.45

Marble Rye Bread - Large

$9.90

Marble Rye Bread - Small

$6.35

Pumpernickle Bread - Large

$9.90

Rye Bread - Large

$9.90

Breakfast & Pastries

Blueberry Scone

$4.25

Apricot Sour Cream Pastry

$4.65

Blueberry Scone

$4.25

Apricot Sour Cream Pastry

Small Apple Turnover

Daintie

Sticky Bun

Cheese Cup

Cakes

Custom Beach Cake

Occasion Cake

Custom Beach Cake

Occasion Cake

7" "Carvel" Cake

7" Fudge Layer Cakes

Cheesecake

Cheesecake-Fruit/Flavored

From $25.70

Cake Toppers

Cake Topper: Baby Shower

Cake Topper: Graduation

Cake Topper: Baby Shower

Cake Topper: Graduation

Cake Topper: Kids Birthday

Cake Topper: Mermaid/Sea Birthday

Cake Topper: Anniversary

Cake Topper: Birthday

Crumb Cake & Pound Cake

**NEW** Cheese Crumb Bun (individual size)

$2.85

*NEW* Cheese Filled Crumb Cake (serves 6-8)

$18.80

**NEW** Cheese Crumb Bun (individual size)

$2.85

*NEW* Cheese Filled Crumb Cake (serves 6-8)

$18.80

Banana Nut Pound Cake

$9.80

Crumb Bun Breakfast Platter

From $39.20

Chocolate Pound Cake

$9.80

Just Mueller's Crumbs

From $9.20

Cupcakes & Brownies

1Lb. Assorted Chocolate Covered Pretzels

$21.55

Brownies

$3.25

1Lb. Assorted Chocolate Covered Pretzels

$21.55

Brownies

$3.25

Cupcakes

$3.05

"Superfood" Specialty Bars

$5.10

Oatmeal Caramel Bar Cookie Bars

$5.10

Flavored Cupcake

$4.40

Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.80

Black & White

$5.10

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Black & White

Large Linzer

Elmo Cookie

Cookie Monster Cookie

$3.95

Assorted Mini Cookies Tray

From $33.30

Dog Biscuits

Dog Biscuits - Half Pound Bag

$11.00

Dog Biscuits - Half Pound Bag

$11.00

Pies

8" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

Coconut Cream Pie

8" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

Coconut Cream Pie

7" Boston Cream Cake

Candles

7" Strawberry Shortcake

Red Velvet Cake

Rolls & Bagels

Onion Rolls

Torpedo Roll

Onion Rolls

Torpedo Roll

Hoagie Roll

Bagel Breakfast Platter

From $29.00

Hamburger or Hotdog Rolls - 6 pack

$5.40

Keto Garlic Cheddar Biscuit (GF ONLY)

$3.85

Drinks/Dairy/Juices/Coffee Beans

8oz Cream Cheese

$4.45

8oz Cream Cheese

$4.45

Gluten Free (Made in facility WITH gluten)

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

Schnibblins: Vegan & Gluten Free "Crumbles" -8oz bag

$10.15

Schnibblins (dairy, gluten, & egg free) Crumb Bums

Schnibblins: Almond Oat Muffin - Gluten, Egg, & Dairy Free

Schnibblins Sunbutter Buddies

$2.50

Merch

Mueller's Sign Key Chains

From $10.00

Donut Key Chains

$8.00

Mueller's Sign Key Chains

From $10.00

Donut Key Chains

$8.00

Mueller's Logo - Youth Short Sleeve

$20.00

Mueller's Logo Long Sleeve

$35.00

Bay Head Pint Glass (2 Pack)

$30.00

Bay Head Jute Tote Bag

$25.00

Occasion Cakes

Custom Beach Cake

Custom Rustic Beach Cake

Custom Beach Cake

Custom Rustic Beach Cake

Edible Image Cake

From $60.00

Occasion Cake

From $37.00

Party Platters

Dessert Platter *Refrigerated*

From $61.95

Crumb Bun Breakfast Platter

From $39.20

Dessert Platter *Refrigerated*

From $61.95

Crumb Bun Breakfast Platter

From $39.20

Bagel Breakfast Platter

From $29.00

1LB Box Mini Cookies- wrapped with ribbon

$22.55

Assorted Mini Cookies Tray

From $33.30

Special Diets

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

Schnibblins: Vegan & Gluten Free "Crumbles" -8oz bag

$10.15

Schnibblins (dairy, gluten, & egg free) Crumb Bums

Schnibblins: Almond Oat Muffin - Gluten, Egg, & Dairy Free

Schnibblins Sunbutter Buddies

$2.50

Schnibblins (Special Diet Items: Dairy & Egg Free

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

'Lil Lemon Oatmeal Pie- DF, EF, & GF

Schnibblins: Lemon Crumb Bars (gluten/dairy/egg free)

Schnibblins: DF, EF, GF Mini Lemon Poppy Cookies

From $10.75

Schnibblins: Vegan & Gluten Free "Crumbles" -8oz bag

$10.15

Schnibblins (dairy, gluten, & egg free) Crumb Bums

Schnibblins: Almond Oat Muffin - Gluten, Egg, & Dairy Free

Refrigerated Cakes & Pies

8" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

Coconut Cream Pie

8" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

Coconut Cream Pie

7" Boston Cream Cake

Candles

7" Strawberry Shortcake

Red Velvet Cake

Refrigerated Pastries

Jumbo Cupcake: Strawberry Shortcake

Jumbo Cupcake: Red Velvet

Jumbo Cupcake: Strawberry Shortcake

Jumbo Cupcake: Red Velvet

Jumbo Cupcake: Carrot

Mini Cheesecake

Napoleon

Cream Puffs

Patriotic

Hamburger Cake

Fondant Flag Cookie

Hamburger Cake

Fondant Flag Cookie

7" Patriotic "Carvel" Cake

$25.70

Hamburger or Hotdog Rolls - 6 pack

$5.40

Rustic Beach Cake

$28.80

Mermaid Cupcake

$4.40

Greeting Cards

Get Well Card - Blank Inside

Sympathy Card - Blank Inside

Get Well Card - Blank Inside

Sympathy Card - Blank Inside

Friendship Card - Blank Inside

Congratulations Card - Blank Inside

Thank You Card - Blank Inside

Birthday Card - Blank Inside